[IUCr Home Page] [Book Review Home Page]

Acta Cryst. (1998). A54, 516-516.

Simulations for solid state physics. An interactive teaching resource for students and teachers.

Edited by Robert H. Silsbee and Jörg Dräger.

Pp. xvii + 348 + CD-ROM. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997. Price £60.00, US $80.00. ISBN 0-521-59094-9.

The authors, physicists at Cornell University, have produced a remarkable work, a combination of computer simulations of basic physical processes at the atomic level, contained on a CD-ROM, and associated tutorials and exercises presented in the book. The simulations are of generally high quality, allowing control over all required parameters, and may be used to help develop understanding at all levels from the purely introductory to the very advanced. They may be run on Windows based computers, Power Macintosh systems, or on UNIX workstations with 1024 × 768 pixel (or better) 256 color displays. Given the required hardware, installation is straightforward and quick. The quality and speed of execution are, of course, platform dependent.

There are 14 simulation packages, covering diffraction, lattice dynamics and related phenomena, dynamics of classical and quantum free electrons, electron energy bands and states, dynamics and transport in single and in partially filled bands, carrier densities and band bending in semiconductors, ferro- and antiferromagnetism and magnetic domains, and dislocations and plastic flow. All are well tried and tested and function smoothly.

The authors' approach throughout, understandably, is very much physics oriented, but crystallographers will find the first three simulations useful in their own teaching, while steering students away from such statements as `there is no direct way to deduce a crystal structure from the diffraction pattern' (p. 27); in this review, I concentrate on them.

Simulation package Bravais covers the fundamentals of crystal lattices and X-ray diffraction, using two-dimensional examples; Laue deals with diffraction in perfect and imperfect one-dimensional crystals; and Born treats the properties of plane waves and lattice dynamics in one dimension.

Bravais offers nine preset simulations, which allow for a wide range of options and exercises, from simple presentation of the basic geometrical ideas to the ability to solve a simple two-atom structure from its diffraction pattern. An attractive feature is the instant side-by-side presentation of structure and diffraction pattern as lattice size and shape and basis position and content are varied.

Laue's nine preset simulations explore the Bragg condition, atomic form factors, the structure factor, order-disorder, atomic displacements and thermal disorder, and even quasicrystals. The immediate effectiveness of these simulations is reduced somewhat by annoying changes of scale in the calculated diffraction patterns that visually obscure the important reciprocal relationships between the sizes of the objects and their diffraction patterns. However, patterns can be copied and stored for later detailed examination.

Born's simulations explore the properties of plane waves, both standing and travelling, the normal modes of a finite chain, wave packets, pulse propagation, the effect of impurities, and anharmonicity. Again, the wide range of available options within each preset lets one use these simulations at all levels of understanding.

The authors do their best to remove any `blackbox' connotations from the simulations by carefully describing the mechanics of each program, the assumptions made, algorithms used, and the actual and potential bugs and problems that may be encountered. They have provided teachers and students of diffraction and solid-state physics, at all levels, with a sophisticated and highly useful tool to help understand fundamental concepts and the often elusive link between algebraic function and physical form. The license agreement included with the hardcover edition allows for network installation of the programs at an educational institution and a paperback edition of the book (ISBN 0-521-59911-3) without CD-ROM is available for student use.

Robert Bryan

Department of Chemistry,
University of Virginia,
Charlottesville,
VA 22901,


Copyright © 1997 International Union of Crystallography

IUCr Webmaster